What Influencers Get Wrong About Appliance Reliability in 2026: The Truth from 33,190 Service Calls

The most-watched appliance rankings on YouTube right now are getting it wrong.

Hundreds of thousands of people are watching them and making decisions based on opinions, not data.

These rankings are built on brand reputations, dramatic stories, and what “feels” reliable.

We take a different approach: actual service data.

We tracked 33,190 service calls last year across Massachusetts, Rhode Island, and Southern New Hampshire, and more than 100,000 in the last three years.

So when a viral video ranks appliances from “disasters” to “worth your money,” we look at what really breaks and what actually holds up.

Because with millions of appliances sold, you can always find bad reviews. That does not mean the whole brand is unreliable.

So let’s go brand by brand. I’ll show you what they said, what we’ve seen in the field, and why service after the sale matters more than any ranking.

In This Article, You’ll Learn:

• Why influencer rankings are built on opinion, not real outcomes
• How horror stories warp online reliability perceptions
• Why reliability varies by product type, not just brand name
• Which video claims hold up, and which fall apart, under real service data
• Why local service access can make or break the ownership experience

What Influencers Get Wrong About Appliance Reliability: The Truth from 33,190 Service Calls 

Quick Take: What 33,190 Real Service Calls Show

This is the difference between what people say online—and what actually happens in homes across New England.

GE Appliances

What the Rankings Say

GE looks like a brand you should be able to trust. But this influencer video calls it "inconsistent quality" and a "service nightmare."

The horror story they highlight is a refrigerator with multiple failures in under a year, followed by a long, frustrating repair delay.

What the Data Shows

GE is not one-size-fits-all. Some categories are excellent. Others face the same challenges as every other brand.

Let’s start with the good news. GE and GE Profile are among the most reliable brands we sell, with an 8–9.2% first-year service rate.

GE stoves and dishwashers also hold up well.

Where the video gets closer to the truth is refrigeration. French door refrigerators are trouble across the board, including GE. That is not unique to GE.

The design itself is the issue: moving frozen cubes through a warm compartment just doesn’t work well.

The Hidden Advantage: Service Access

What the rankings don’t talk about is service. GE has one of the deepest service networks in the country, which matters when something breaks.

The Real Takeaway on GE

• 8–9.2% service rate overall
• Solid performance in stoves and dishwashers
• Refrigerators struggle with the same flaws as other brands
• Strong national service network

GE is a smart buy if you pick the right product. Pairing reliability with strong service is what keeps small problems from turning into big regrets.

🔍 Read more: Appliance Service 2026: Why Most Stores Skip It & How to Protect Yourself

Looking for answers about Appliances?

Short on time? Download our free Appliance Buying Guide.

LG

What the Rankings Say

LG looks sleek. But according to the video, it’s all style and no substance.

They love the line “smart tech, dumb reliability.” And they almost always tie it to one thing:refrigerator compressor failures.

Then come the stories: early breakdowns, long waits, expensive repairs.

What the Data Shows

LG is the opposite of what the rankings say. In our latest numbers, LG is the second most reliable brand overall, with a 5.5% first-year service rate.

And LG isn’t just strong in one category. They show up at the top across the board:

• #1 in counter-depth refrigerator reliability: 10.1%
• #1 in front-load washer reliability: 2.7%
• #1 in compact washer reliability: 4.1%
• #1 in induction range reliability: 4.6%
• #1 in electric range reliability: 4.1%
• #2 in gas range reliability: 4.8%

That’s not “all style.” That’s a brand that’s consistently performing in multiple categories.

So Why the Bad Reputation?

First, refrigerators.

LG has had compressor issues. That’s real.

But the scale is massive. LG sells millions of refrigerators. So even a normal compressor failure rate of 1.1% within five years is an issue, esecially on the service side. 

Second, dishwashers this year.

A lot of the recent negativity is coming from dishwasher rack issues. It's one roller on their most popular model. 

Although any problems on new products are annoying, the roller is a simple fix. 

Without that one issue, LG dishwashers would again be number 1 for reliability. Better than Miele or Bosch.

It’s not a compressor problem. It’s not a “the whole brand is junk” problem.

It’s a very specific issue that’s annoying, visible, and easy to post about.

The Real Problem: Who Fixes It?

LG’s biggest issue isn’t quality. It’s service. They’re building out a service network, but that will take years (we know all too well).

That doesn’t mean their products break more often. It means you need to know who’s going to fix it before you buy.

The Real Takeaway on LG

• Second most reliable brand overall: 5.5% first-year service
• Top performers in laundry and cooking, with multiple #1 reliability spots
• Refrigerator complaints are real, but reviews exaggerate the problem because of volume
• Recent negative press is also driven by dishwasher rack issues
• Service coverage varies, so confirm local support before you buy

Bottom line: LG makes some of the most reliable appliances you can buy. Just make sure you have a real service plan where you live.

🔍 Read more: The Most Reliable Appliance Brands

Whirlpool, Maytag, Amana, and KitchenAid

What the Rankings Say

The video spreads these brands across the spectrum: Amana is labeled “bottom tier,” Whirlpool is “middling,” Maytag is framed as “the reliable rebel,” and KitchenAid gets called “premium in name only.”

But here’s the problem: they all come from the same place. Literally.

Why the Differences Are Smaller Than They Seem

Look at a Whirlpool refrigerator. Now a KitchenAid. Then a Maytag.

The parts line up. The layouts are nearly identical. The control panels feel the same.

The same goes for their stoves: same ovens, same burners, same brains.

That’s because most of these products are built in the same factories, on the same platforms, by the same company.

Why the Rankings Get It Wrong

You’re not comparing different machines. You’re comparing:

• The same refrigerator with a different badge
• The same range with a new control face
• The same dishwasher with one extra cycle

The core parts are the same. The differences are mostly cosmetic or minor features layered on top.

What About KitchenAid?

KitchenAid is a partial exception.

Their new range platform just launched. It’s too soon to call long-term reliability, but it is a real change under the hood.

KitchenAid dishwashers are also a standout. They’re built differently from the rest of the Whirlpool family, and it shows.

At 8.2% first-year service, they rank fifth overall, just behind Miele, Bosch Benchmark, Bosch, and Thermador.

The Real Takeaway on the Whirlpool Family

• Whirlpool, Maytag, Amana, and many KitchenAid models share the same platforms
• Most differences come down to styling and features, not reliability
• Rankings that spread them apart are misleading
• KitchenAid dishwashers are the exception: well-built and statistically strong

🔍Read more: Who Really Makes Your Appliances? A Guide to Relabeled Brands and What They're Worth

Bosch

What the Rankings Say

Bosch is labeled a “premium gamble.” According to the video, they start strong, but wear down fast. The claim is that you’re paying top dollar for a brand that might not hold up.

It’s a sharp line, but it’s built on a few owner stories and skips entire categories.

What the Data Shows

Bosch isn’t a gamble. It’s one of the safest bets you can make.

Let’s start with dishwashers. Bosch has delivered strong, consistent reliability for years. In our data, 7.7% of Bosch dishwashers needed service in the first year, just behind Miele.

But Bosch’s reliability doesn’t stop there:

• Their refrigerators are the third most reliable we sell (after LG and GE).
• Their induction cooktops are the most reliable in that entire category, and in the top three for induction ranges.

These are not one-hit wonders. The service data is consistent across platforms and product lines.

The Real Takeaway on Bosch

• Bosch is strong across dishwashing, refrigeration, and induction
• 7.7% service on dishwashers is second only to Miele
• Refrigerators and induction cooking lead the category in reliability
• No signs of slipping reliability in real-world service data

The “premium gamble” claim doesn’t hold up. Bosch is one of the most consistent, quietly reliable brands on the market.

Speed Queen

What the Rankings Say

Speed Queen is called “bulletproof.” The video praises its simple design, long life, and nearly indestructible construction. For once, the ranking sounds reasonable.

But even praise can be misleading if it skips the trade-offs.

What the Data Shows

Speed Queen is one of the most reliable laundry brands we sell. Top-load washers needed service just 4.6% of the time in the first year. That’s outstanding.

They earn that record by keeping things simple:

• Fewer electronics
• Fewer features
• Proven mechanical designs

Less complexity means fewer things break. But simplicity comes with trade-offs.

What the Rankings Leave Out

Speed Queen washers are smaller. A typical top-load model offers about 2.7 cubic feet of usable space and costs around $1,500.

Compare that to a $1,000 LG or GE washer with up to 5.3 cubic feet. That’s nearly double the space for less money.

The “bulletproof” label fits, but only if you’re okay with paying more for less space.

The Real Takeaway on Speed Queen

• 4.6% first-year service rate equals top-tier reliability
• Built for durability, not bells and whistles
• Smaller capacity than most competitors
• Higher price per cubic foot

It’s a great choice when durability matters most. Just know what you’re trading for that reliability.

🔍Read more: Speed Queen Top-Load Washer Review 2025: Reliability, Costs & Drawbacks

Miele

What the Rankings Say

Miele is crowned the “gold standard.” The video calls it “virtually flawless,” “built to last 20 years,” and the most reliable brand you can buy.

That reputation didn’t come out of nowhere, but it’s not the full story.

What the Data Shows

Miele makes excellent products, no question. But not every Miele appliance is the best in its category.

Let’s start with dishwashers. This is where Miele lives up to the hype. 

In our service data, only 5.6% of Miele dishwashers required service in the first year, the most reliable in our lineup.

But elsewhere:

• In compact laundry, LG and Bosch are more reliable in year one.
• In induction cooking, Bosch (and its sister brands) outperform Miele in long-term service rates.

What About the “20-Year Lifespan” Claim?

You hear it everywhere, but it’s not backed by warranty coverage, parts guarantees, or statistical data.

If any brand could promise 20 years, they’d offer 10- or 15-year full coverage. No one does.

What the Rankings Leave Out

Miele appliances are expensive. You’re often paying a premium for premium build quality, but not always for the most reliable result.

Miele earns its reputation in dishwashing, but no brand is number one in every category.

The Real Takeaway on Miele

• Best dishwasher reliability we track (5.5%)
• Excellent engineering across the lineup
• Not the most reliable in compact laundry or induction cooking
• Expensive, with no guaranteed lifespan

If you buy Miele, buy it for the right reasons and for the products where it really shines.

Final Takeaway

Every brand in this article has nightmare stories online. That’s what viral rankings feed on.

But one dramatic failure isn’t the same as real reliability. What one person posts on Reddit or YouTube is not the same as tracking 33,190 service calls.

Here’s what that data shows:

• No brand is perfect across the board
• Some brands are excellent in one category and average in another
• A smart appliance purchase depends on the product, not just the logo

What matters even more is what happens after the sale, because something will eventually break.

When it does, the difference is whether it gets fixed fast or turns into a months-long headache.

That’s why we publish service rates. It’s also why we only recommend what we can actually support.

Ready to Buy Without the Guesswork?

You can shop online, start a live chat, or visit one of our six showrooms across Massachusetts. We deliver most appliances within 48 hours, and we service what we sell.

👉 Click here to browse, chat, or find a showroom near you.

Additional Resources

Get the free Yale Appliance Buying Guide. It has features, specs, and inside tips to all the brands like Sub-Zero, Thermador, Bosch, and Miele. It covers built-ins, counter depth, freestanding vs. slide-in, and much more (plus a ton of good product shots). Well over 1 million people have read a Yale Guide.

Related Articles:

• Is Appliance Delivery Ever Free?
• What You Should Expect From an Appliance Delivery
• How to Plan Your Kitchen Appliance Project