Home Appliance + Lighting Blog
Honest insights, opinions and resources about buying home appliances, lighting and plumbing

Most Reliable Freestanding Gas Ranges (Reviews/Ratings)

This is our 8th or 9th most reliable post. Gas ranges should have been one of the first as the category is over 60% of the market. We will reiterate the service formula, but reliability is a very elusive measurement in our industry.

Yale Framingham Freestanding Ranges
Yale Framingham Freestanding Ranges

Cars have JD Power rankings for quality. Appliances have Consumer Reports, but I have not ever understood the baseline measurement of that magazine. How can the same range with a different label perform so differently? It does not seem possible.

Anyway, let me show you the formula and then review the most reliable gas ranges.

Reliability Measurements

Every day, we have 23 service techs performing 8-10 service calls with another 110 or so on Saturday. We then look at sales in that period and divide for the percentage.

We do not scrub the data. Every time you have a technician visit, it will count as a service call. We do not include damage and phone resolutions as service calls.

I only cover the first year, because warranty service is free for the first year, so there is a greater and more accurate pool of data.

So, let's take a look. 

Most Reliable Gas Ranges

Brand Units Sold  Units Serviced  Service Rate 
Whirlpool 259 7 2.70%
Amana 54 2 3.70%
Frigidaire  324 13 4.01%
Samsung  112 6 5.36%
Frigidaire Gallery 224 20 8.93%
Frigidaire Pro 62  9.68%
Maytag 28 3 10.71%
Bosch  522 60 11.49%
KitchenAid 161 21 13.04%
JennAir  284 59 20.77%
Bosch Benchmark 65 24 36.92%
Electrolux 57 23 40.35%
Blomberg  14 6 42.86%


What is the Most Reliable?

Answering this question will require an explanation.

Before you buy a Whirlpool, Maytag or Amana range, most of these units were sold on jobs to builders. It is unclear if people are actually using these ranges just yet. I would wait and see for next year.

Whirlpool's upscale brands KitchenAid and Jenn-Air fared comparatively well given they both introduced newer products.

Samsung looks good, but many of these products were sold on Black Friday. That’s not a year as of yet, but their whole line seems to be performing well.

Bosch is interesting. Their regular ranges have a respectable 11.49%, but their Benchmark is over 30%. Well, Benchmark is brand new to gas ranges, so it is somewhat expected with introductions. Their regular line was produced by Frigidaire.

Speaking of which, Electrolux has issues. They have lagged a bit while waiting for their failed merger with GE. Yet they manufacture Frigidaire, which seems to be the most regularly reliable product sold across all product lines.

Which One Should You Buy?

Everyone thinks I am a high-end guy, but Frigidaire (or anything that doesn’t break) is probably my favorite line. Samsung is worth a look as is KitchenAid and Jenn-Air. Bosch will figure it out.

Lastly, you should be concerned when the products actually break. The best companies with the quickest turnarounds for parts are Whirlpool companies, Frigidaire/Electrolux and Bosch. The Korean companies, Samsung and LG, need more time.

Now all you have to do is find someone credible to actually send a technician to make repairs, which is almost a certainty in a new kitchen within the first year.

Most Reliable Appliances Series

Additional Resources

Need more information on Gas Ranges? Download the Yale Gas Cooking Buying Guide with specs, features and detailed profiles to all the brands. Well over 160,000 people have read a Yale Guide.

View our gas cooking buying guide

Topics: Whirlpool, Frigidaire, Website, Electrolux, KitchenAid, Maytag, Freestanding Ranges, Most Reliable Appliances

About The Author

Steve Sheinkopf

My goal has always been simple: I want Yale to be the best retail experience anywhere. I have tried to create a compelling environment for customers and employees alike

Share This Article

View our Resource Center
Remodeling and Home Design

Subscribe to Email Updates


see all

A note about pricing

Pricing on this blog is for reference only and may include time sensitive rebates. We make every attempt to provide accurate pricing at time of publishing.

Please call the store for most accurate price.