Island Hoods vs Downdraft Ranges (Reviews/Prices/Ratings)

Steve Sheinkopf  |  September 03, 2012  |  3 Min. Read

Island Hoods  |  Ventilation  |  Downdrafts

Start finding answers in our Resource Center full of videos, buying guides, and checklists

Start Here

Island Hoods vs Downdraft Ranges

Island hoods are four sided and affixed to the ceiling instead of a wall. They are designed to be used over an island in the middle of the room (hence the name). Back in the dark ages, when I was selling appliances, island hoods were clearly the worst category. Best seller in 1986, the Broan "Chuck Wagon" hood, followed by an equally awful Nutone hood. Imagine trying to sell that to a client with a contemporary kitchen.

I couldn't. We sold downdrafts instead. Downdrafts are a good aesthetic option, but not as good for ventilation. Smoke is normally captured in the plenum of a hood, but there is no capture area in a downdraft. Also, smoke travels up, so the downdrafts must work twice as hard with liitle or no capture area. However, for most cooking, downdrafts are still functional.

In the mid 1990s, island hoods became more popular, because of an influx of European imports. The new hoods were both beautiful and functional in gleaming stainless steel. A hood really handles large volumes of steam and grease better than a downdraft.

Island Hoods vs Downdrafts

Island Hoods

yale island hood RH00436G thermador island hood HPIN42HS bosch island hood DIE165RUC jennair island hood JXI5036WS

Yale Hood RH00436G - $999.99

Thermador HPIN42HS - $2649.00

Bosch DIE165RUC - $2299.00

Jenn-Air JXI5036WS - $2499.00

Downdrafts

jennair slidein downdraft range JES9800CAS broan downdraft range hood 273001

Jenn-Air JES9800CAS

Broan 273001

The answer is as much about aesthetics as function. The downdraft disappears in the cabinet whereas the island hood becomes a design element in your kitchen. Functionally, there is no contest. The island hood is designed for any type of cooking, even professional (with the suitable hood). Downdrafts are not manufactured for that type of volume.

So the decision is based on how much you cook and the aesthetics of what you like to see.

For more information about terms, features and how to size a hood , read the Yale Ventilation Buyers Guide.

Additional Resources

Why Should You Trust Us?

It seems that every appliance review has nothing but glowing comments about almost every product, yet you read customer reviews and they are almost universally bad.

We are here to fill in the disconnect. We'll give you the best features, and the drawbacks as well, including reliability based on over 37,000 calls performed by our service team just last year. Our goal is to give you ALL the information so you know what's right for you.

Please consider subscribing or adding to the conversation in the comments below. We appreciate you stopping by.

Steve Sheinkopf

Steve is the third-generation CEO of Yale and a lifelong Bostonian. He currently resides in Boston, one mile from where he was born. Despite being one of the worst goalies of all time, he is a huge hockey fan of college hockey and the Boston Bruins. The love of his life is his daughter Sophie.

Steve has also been featured in numerous publications such as the New York Times, Consumer Reports, The Boston Globe, Bloomberg Radio, the New York Post, The Wall Street Journal, and Entrepreneur, for his knowledge of how to buy appliances and appliance repair.

A Note About Pricing

Pricing on this blog is for reference only and may include time sensitive rebates. We make every attempt to provide accurate pricing at time of publishing. Please call the stores for most accurate price.

Suggested Articles